Otto McGavin works for TBII — a future interplanetary security agency — as an agent trained in an extraordinary technique: he can so thoroughly assume another identity that he effectively becomes that person, thinking their thoughts, feeling their feelings, inhabiting their consciousness. The technique is perfect for espionage. It is destroying him. The novel is structured as a series of mission reports, between which we watch Otto slowly losing track of which consciousness is originally his.
Published Reviews
"Haldeman's most underrated novel, and possibly his most philosophically ambitious. The Forever War gets the fame, but All My Sins Remembered gets the question right: not 'what does war do to bodies' but 'what does moral compromise do to souls.'"
"A deeply unsettling novel about the cost of service — any service — when that service requires you to become someone you're not. The most psychologically honest spy novel in science fiction."
Our Musings
The question that runs through All My Sins Remembered — and through this entire list of books, if you look at it from the right angle — is the question of the self under pressure. What is the self? What holds it together? And what happens when the conditions of your life systematically attack the coherence of your own identity? Haldeman's answer is as dark as any on this list, and more intimately human than most.
Otto McGavin is not an immortal accumulating centuries of borrowed memories. He is not a philosopher in a medieval monastery wrestling with questions of pure knowledge. He is a spy — a working-class hero of the intelligence services, a man who took a job and discovered, too late, that the job was consuming him from the inside. His technique — the deep identity immersion that makes him so valuable to TBII — is a form of radical empathy weaponized. To inhabit another consciousness fully enough to pass as that person, you have to genuinely become them. You have to feel what they feel, think the way they think, care about what they care about. And every time you do that, you bring a piece of them back. The residue accumulates. The original self gets harder to locate.
The Vietnam Subtext
Haldeman is a Vietnam veteran, and his best work is always, at some level, about what it costs to do things you know are wrong because the system you're inside has decided they're necessary. The Forever War is the most famous expression of this; All My Sins Remembered is the most intimate. Otto's problem is not just psychological dissociation; it is moral dissociation. He has been required, in the course of his missions, to do things he finds repugnant. He has done them because they were, within the framework of TBII's logic, necessary. And the necessity doesn't make them sit better in the conscience. The sins accumulate with the identities.
The title is from a prayer — specifically, the prayer of confession: "I confess to Almighty God, and to you my brothers and sisters, that I have greatly sinned... through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault. Therefore I ask blessed Mary ever-Virgin... and you, my brothers and sisters, to pray for me to the Lord our God." The irony is precise: Otto cannot confess, because confession requires a stable self to be the confessor, and his self has been so thoroughly distributed across other identities that the original — the one that would bear the guilt — is no longer easy to locate.
The Structure of the Breakdown
The novel's form is brilliantly chosen: alternating mission reports (cold, procedural, professional) with first-person reflections (increasingly confused, increasingly frightened). The reports get the job done. The reflections are the cost. Haldeman uses the contrast to dramatize the split that is destroying Otto: the professional self that functions perfectly in the field, and the personal self that is barely holding on between missions. The gap between them widens over the course of the novel until it becomes impossible to bridge.
This structure also makes the novel feel extraordinarily contemporary. We live in a professional culture that rewards the capacity to compartmentalize — to perform competence in the workplace while managing personal disintegration in private, to be your "work self" and your "real self" and to maintain the fiction that these are the same person. Otto is an extreme version of a familiar pathology. His crisis is ours, dialed up to eleven.
Why This Book Matters
We include All My Sins Remembered partly to introduce it to readers who may have missed it — it has never had the cultural prominence its quality deserves — and partly because it asks, more directly than any other book on this list, what the survival of the self actually requires in practical terms. Kayin, in Masks of God, is given an almost mystical framework for the preservation of selfhood: the Numen, the borrowed memories, the cosmic stakes. Otto is given no such framework. He has only his own exhausted consciousness and the question of whether there's still enough of him left to want to be saved.
His answer, when it comes, is among the most moving in science fiction. We won't tell you what it is. But the title, by the end, means something entirely different from what it meant at the beginning.
Reader Comments